00:00
00:00
fabbemannen

74 Audio Reviews

30 w/ Responses

Ok...

Hmm, not yet
The audiobalance and quality wasn't the best :/
If the main melody was a little louder, then it would be a really sweet tune.
Right now it gets unnoticed cause of the strings

Some more work on it and it would be really nice

Ironclover responds:

I'll put in a consideration of a second version and your suggestions, thank you :)

Sweet

I don't know what to say about this...
I think it sounds really wonderful and beautiful, but still empty for getting such a high score (which isn't so high anymore)
Let's put it like this:
You posted it on youtube with a video of you playing it = Amazing
You posted it on newgrounds = It feels empty and should have some background behind it

Well, nice work anyhow

Ocarina-Kid responds:

I completely agree, this shouldn't even be in the top 5. Thanks for the honesty and review, appreciate it :)

Could get a higher ranking, or lower

This is kinda how I assume a remake of Dr.Mario would sound (in space!?)
It could use some improvements here and there
Like the sound at 0:14-0:15

not the best version

I enjoy the youtube version of this song much better and this one just doesn't make it

Really good!

I really love this tune you have made hear!
Great quality, great composition, and perfectly suited for what you made it for
It sounds like a mix between Boogie-Woogie and old honky-tonk music, and as a pianist and westernfan I love them both!

Favorized, 5-ranked and downloaded

medievalstylish

I have to agree with the others here. You succeded to pull off a repetitive song and make it sound like it wasn't
9.5 rounded up to 10 ;)
Good job here!

Halindir responds:

Thank you very much fabbermannen, im glad you enjoyed it :)

(Your Kirby remix is pretty awesome!)

Sweet! =D

Intro: Classic ragtime 5/5
Mario part: Spot on! 5/5
Solo between the parts: Epic! 5/5
Zelda part: Should have been in a brighter chord 3/5
Ending: Classic, but not my taste 4/5
Overall: 5/5 and 9,5/10

Chords =D

This needs more chords and a better quality, but still good ;)
D,G,C,F,G (a and b tone) etc.

____

I would say that it's a good song for being your first one.
It's not good enough to keep people entertained just by listening to this song alone, but maybe as a background theme for something

Feddey responds:

Thx man! it was'nt ment like a serious subissoin, just for fun! =)

Victory!

Nice one! As a huge pianofan I really enjoyed this.
You made it float in really nice with the other instruments.

I think that it should have been a better pianosound, instead of the electric "lp" sound that you use now

NikolaosTheDark responds:

Thanks! Sorry that I couldn't get to the review until the end of May, but I haven't been here in a while.

You're right about the piano sound. I'm getting sick of a lot of orchestral sounds in general. I'm keeping my ears open for more realistic synths, though, and I hope to get some more refined sounds in the coming months.

Thanks again for the review.

Age 30, Male

John Bauer

Hedesunda

Joined on 9/9/10

Level:
17
Exp Points:
3,124 / 3,210
Exp Rank:
17,494
Vote Power:
5.92 votes
Rank:
Civilian
Global Rank:
> 100,000
Blams:
1
Saves:
8
B/P Bonus:
0%
Whistle:
Normal
Medals:
211